The government sees the Thames Gateway as the answer to the south east's housing shortage. But is it all it's cracked up to be? Mark Smulian looks at the opportunities for housebuilders east of the meridian and some of the challenges still to be overcome
But to get from here to there, housebuilders will have to overcome problems of
planning policy, site availability, decontamination, access, infrastructure
development and skills and materials supply. So far, 1 billion of public investment has been announced, which will go some way towards removing these hurdles.
limitless opportunities
Thereason such a vast and complex area of brownfield land is available is that,
unlike most of the south east, the Gateway was primarily an industrial area, in
which the dock, oil refining, cement and quarrying industries have declined
sharply. This gives almost limitless development opportunities, but those with memories ofthe London Docklands Development Corporation's hands-off approach to planningcontrols in the 1980s will find things different this time.
Even though the urban development corporations are back, the Gateway looks set to be far more coherently planned than was Docklands. The government does not just
want to stand back and see what happens: it wants to see sustainable
communities created where people can both live and work.
The Gateway will thus be neither an enormous dormitory for London commuters nor the preserve of luxury housing.
Planning policy for the Gateway is split a number of ways. The government has laid down its overall vision of sustainable communities, but with two exceptions the
power to grant planning permission rests with any of more than a dozen local
authorities. While these councils are signed up to the concept of encouraging
regeneration, they are free to set their own planning policies and so there may
not be a consistent approach to housebuilding across the whole Gateway.
The exceptions are two urban development corporations established by the
government.
One covers the same area as Thurrock Council and was set up at the council's
request so that the UDC's special compulsory purchase and land assembly powers
could be applied to the highly complex patchwork of brownfield land in the
area. The other covers three geographically separate chunks of the banks of the
Thames in east London: the Lower Lea Valley, Barking Reach and Thamesmead/Erith. It too will be able to compulsorily purchase and assemble sites, and put in access and utilities, though there is some fear that it will become distracted by preparations for the Olympic Games bid, the site for which is in the Lower Lea Valley.
Despite its problems, the Gateway has many positives. It is all within easy reach of London, and so has a ready-made demand from home buyers; the river frontage ought to provide a major selling point, and the new stations on the Channel Tunnel rail link, at Stratford and Ebbsfleet, make it an attractive area for businesses
that want to be in rapid reach of Europe.
Ebbsfleet provides an example of plans for the sort of sustainable development that so preoccupies the government. The station will be near to the Eastern Quarry, an enormous hole in the ground originally owned by Blue Circle, adjacent to the former quarry in which the Bluewater shopping centre was built in the late
1990s. One of the largest planning applications ever seen has been made to create six self-contained villages in the former quarry.
sustainable communities
The idea is that the people who eventually live there will be able to work nearby.
As the new housing areas are built, so will be business parks and light
industrial estates to provide employment, plus schools, hospitals, shops and
leisure facilities to meet the needs of these new communities.
They should become places in which people can settle long term. Although residents cannot be prevented from commuting to London, the government's hope is that these developments will become towns in their own right, or substantial
extensions to existing towns.
Thus 'sustainability' in the Thames Gateway does not mean only that
housebuilders will be expected to use environmentally friendly materials and
design energy efficient homes, though they will be, but also that they must
design developments that fit this model of creating new communities.
Builders will have to provide everything from luxury homes to starter flats and can certainly expect that planning agreements will require a proportion of social
housing on most sites, probably designed in a way that prevents these homes
from being visually different from their owner occupied neighbours. Planners are therefore unlikely to look kindly on proposals for vast estates of
five-bedroom executive homes.
Bellway Homes has entered a joint venture with English Partnerships, the government's regeneration agency, to develop 100 hectares of Barking Reach.
They will share investment costs to create a community with more than 10,000 mixed
tenure homes over 15 years. The agency has sustainable regeneration, housing
and strategic brownfield land management as its three main areas of activity
and is able to use public money to remediate contaminated sites, which is its
main activity in the Gateway.
Ian Cox, a director of Bellway, approaches government regeneration initiatives by
setting up a structure to fit, in this case a company devoted to the Thames
Gateway. It concentrates on both mixed tenure and in some cases mixed use
developments.
"We have strong relationships with the London Development Agency, English
Partnerships and the local authorities so we feel ourselves part of an overall
regeneration jigsaw within a long-term effort," says Cox. "The
difference between ourselves and some other builders is that we have always
developed sites where we expect a range of affordable housing will be provided,
and we calculate the development's cost on the assumption that affordable
housing will be part of it."
range of housing
Cherry feels that "social sustainability" is too often ignored and that the
aim in the Gateway should be to recreate a version of the traditional village
with "housing opportunities appropriate to people from starter flats to
retirement homes in nice places where people might even wish to spend their
whole life". He points out that the proportion of the population in owner occupation is unlikely ever to much exceed 70%.
Therefore homes for rent, whether in the private or social sector, must be built as an integral part of these developments to help achieve sustainability, and not
just tacked on because the planners have put their foot down. "A lot of
people, even in our industry, just think of sustainability in environmental
terms but the social aspect is very important," says Cherry.
"We do need five-bedroom homes, because we need to attract the wealth creators to
live in the area alongside the people who live in affordable housing, and it is
essential we get that mix. The Thames Gateway is a huge opportunity for
builders if we get it right."
However the Thames Gateway challenges are solved the housebuilding industry will have to get the immense opportunity offered by the Gateway right. As Cherry says:
"We must find solutions that work and not repeat the mistakes of system
building from the 1960s, much of which we are now having to demolish." Transport remains a difficult issue for the Gateway.
Gateway to a promised land
Housebuilder February 2004
"Planning requirements can be imposed but we try to make sure that our developments will be the beneficiaries," he says. "For example, if we put in the infrastructure for a primary school that is always good for the people who will move into our homes. Wetake the long-term view and the planning gain can mean that our sales benefit.You have got to take a 'holistic' approach, although I hate that word." Barking will benefit from extensions to the Docklands Light Railway and there have already been improvements to the train services and the A13.